Menu of Calabria Pizza in Hamilton, Ohio, USA

Menu Overview

Calabria Pizza, nestled at 1010 Main St, Hamilton, Ohio, offers a compelling slice of authentic New York–style pizza that firmly establishes itself in the local culinary scene. This takeaway spot excels not just in its pizza but across a thoughtfully curated menu that showcases Italian classics with a modern twist.

Starting with their pizza, the crisp, crunchy crust strikes a perfect balance that evokes the streets of New York. Customers consistently praise the authentic flavor, with toppings that remain generous and fresh. As Rob points out, the crust has just the right texture—crispy yet tender beneath a blanket of well-melted cheese and rich, savory sauce. The pepperoni pizza particularly stands out with its balanced seasoning and traditional appeal. It’s clear Calabria Pizza aims for a genuine New York experience, a sentiment echoed by locals and newcomers alike.

Beyond pizza, Calabria excels in its pasta offerings, each dish rich in flavor and comfort. The Baked Ziti envelops tender pasta in a hearty tomato sauce, blanketed with melted mozzarella—a harmonious combination that feels both homely and satisfying. The Ziti Alfredo with Chicken layers grilled poultry in a luscious homemade alfredo, merging creamy texture with a robust, savory profile. The Cheese Ravioli in housemade tomato sauce offers a delicate balance of cheese and herbs, while the Stuffed Shells bring a rich, creamy ricotta filling that lingers on the palate.

Salads provide a fresh, crisp contrast to the heartier dishes. The Garden Salad offers classic simplicity with crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, onions, and cucumbers, while the Chicken Salad integrates grilled chicken for added protein and flavor—perfect for those seeking a lighter but still satisfying option.

For dessert, Calabria Pizza holds nothing back in delivering Italian indulgence. The New York Cheesecake is a standout—rich and creamy atop a buttery graham cracker crust, it’s a fitting finale to the meal. Equally compelling is their Tiramisu, with layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone that evoke traditional Italian patisserie without pretension. The moist Carrot Cake with cream cheese frosting and the decadent Chocolate Cake provide additional sweet notes that round out the menu elegantly.

Customer testimonials underscore the consistent quality and friendly service that define Calabria Pizza. From Joe Cox’s catering praise to Justin Bobbitt’s enthusiastic comparisons with former local favorites, it’s clear this restaurant has carved a special place in Hamilton’s dining landscape. Even those familiar with the Bronx’s pizza traditions, like Cheikh Ndiaye, find Calabria’s offerings to be among the closest to true New York pizza they’ve discovered locally.

In sum, Calabria Pizza is more than a takeaway spot—it’s a culinary bridge between traditional Italian-American comfort and the hunger for authentic New York flavors. Each dish reflects care, quality ingredients, and skillful preparation. For anyone craving a taste of New York-style pizza paired with a broad, satisfying Italian menu, Calabria Pizza is a worthy destination.